Danielle Dietrich Dabbs is a 2002 Oak Hills graduate. As a senior Danielle was named first team all-state in two sports, basketball and soccer. In basketball, Danielle led the team to the first Oak Hills GMC title in 2000. She was named first team all-conference three straight years, first team all-city for two years and was a part of the first Oak Hills girls' basketball city title team in 2002. As a part of the soccer team, Danielle still holds the single season scoring record. She was a four year letter winner. Danielle was named all-conference, all city and all state for her efforts. After Oak Hills, Danielle was awarded a soccer scholarship to the Ohio State University. While at OSU, she was a member of the Big Ten Tournament Champion team and named to the All-Big Ten All Freshman Team. She was a three year winner of the All-Big Ten Academic Award and a Big 10 Medal of Honor Finalist 

Dave Burke is a 1990 Oak Hills graduate. Dave has been called one of the best football players in the history of Oak Hills. He was a two year varsity letter winner and team captain. Dave was an important part of the 1988 Metro County Conference League Champion team. In his senior season Dave was named first team all-conference, first team all-southwest district and first team all-state. After his career at Oak Hills ended Dave continued his playing days at Thomas More College. To date Dave still holds the school record for most tackles in a single game at 28 vs. Earlham College. 

Don Ruehl from the Class of 1984, and is one of the best basketball players in Oak Hills High School history. Don has been described as the ultimate teammate and leader by former coaches and players. He was a two sport athlete at Oak Hills - playing both soccer and basketball. As a member of the soccer team, Don was awarded all leagues as a senior in 1984. Don led the basketball program to a city title in 1984. The team finished the year ranked number four in the state as league, sectional and district champions. Individually, Don was named all-conference, all city and all state for his efforts. After high school, Don was awarded a basketball scholarship to the University of Cincinnati where he played for four years. 

Jackie Cornelius Bedel was a three sport varsity letter winner at Oak Hills, graduating in the Class of 2001. She was a three year varsity letter in winner in both basketball and volleyball. Jackie was a captain of the 2000-2001 GMC Champion and District Champion basketball team and was named first team all-league and first team all-city in her senior season. As a member of the Oak Hills softball team, Jackie was a four year varsity letter winner. In her season she was named all-conference, all city, all southwest district and honorable mention allstate. She continued her softball career on scholarship at Cleveland State University where she graduated from in 2005. During her collegiate career Jackie was named to the Horizon League 1st team in 2005 and well as to the Horizon All-Tournament Team. She was a three time Academic All-Conference Selection. Jackie continued her playing career after college by competing in the Vienna Wanders European Pro League and with the Michigan Ice in the US Women's Fast Pitch League. 

Mike Weadick lettered in football, wrestling, and track while a student athlete at Oak Hills. As a captain of the football team, Mike was a middle linebacker. He was a member of the 1976 conference championship team earning all-league status his senior year. In wrestling, Mike was a league, city and district champion in 1977. He qualified for the state finals his senior season finishing third overall. Mike went on to DePauw University on a football scholarship.